Kristin Cavallari is reminiscing about a past love.
The Hills alum, 36, took a trip down memory lane and recalled her high school relationship with Matt Leinart, who won the Heisman Trophy during his time as a quarterback at the University of Southern California from 2001 to 2005.
“I’m actually still good friends with Matt. Matt is the nicest human being on the planet,” Kristin told her co-host Stephen Colletti on their Dear Media podcast, Back to the Beach. “He’s such a great guy.”
“I dated him when I was 18, my second half of my senior year. He was a five-year senior at USC,” she added. “He was on top of the world that year. I was so excited about it, clearly, like no chill whatsoever but it was a big deal for me.“
Colletti then referred to the current Fox Sports analyst, 39, as his co-host’s “first quarterback.”
“Ah God, my first quarterback… I dated a couple athletes in my day, I will say,” she responded.
The Uncommon James founder revealed that has since had a change of heart about dating athletes.
“Here’s my deal. I dated a hockey player. For me, now in my life where I’m at, it’s more about schedules,” she explained. “So baseball, they’re gone all the time. Basketball, they’re gone all the time. Football’s reasonable. Hockey, they’re gone a lot, but it’s doable.”
“To be honest — I don’t want to say anything I’m going to end up regretting — but I don’t think I want to date another athlete,” she admitted. “I’ve done that. I want to leave that in the past.”
RELATED VIDEO: Kristin Cavallari Says She’s ‘Grown Up’ a Lot Since Jay Cutler Split: I’ve ‘Closed That Chapter’
This isn’t the first time that Cavallari has opened up about her perspective on dating.
In July, Cavallari spoke about dating on her own terms. During an appearance on the Not Skinny But Not Fat podcast, the jewelry designer revealed she’s been using her Instagram account like a dating app — with a few rules in place.
“Sorry,” Cavallari explained at the time. “I’m only gonna go for the verified!”
Cavallari told host Amanda Hirsch she is “not gonna settle,” and her method for weeding through the messages has been working well. “I’ve actually been on quite a few dates,” she said.
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
Cavallari went on to explain that it is much easier to vet people who have already been Instagram-verified, and although she’s looking for “a businessman who no one knows,” anyone with a blue checkmark could still make the cut.
“I can’t filter through all of my DMs [direct messages], but I can see those blue checkmarks, honey!” the Laguna Beach alum said. “I don’t like people that often, and I’m pretty picky, I guess, but I’m not gonna settle. I’m gonna stay picky.”